Property manager discussing rental pricing with a landlord in Salt Lake City

How Much Does It Cost to Pay Someone to Manage a Rental Property?

/by

The Real Cost of Stress-Free Property Ownership

If you own rental property in Utah and you’ve ever thought, “Maybe I should hire a property manager,” you’re not alone. Between late-night maintenance calls, chasing rent, and handling leases, managing rentals can feel like a second full-time job. The big question is always the same: what will it actually cost me to pay someone else to handle it? In this guide, we’ll break down what property management fees really include, what affects those costs, and how smart landlords use professional management to make more, not less, from their rentals.

What We’ll Cover:

Average Property Management Costs in Utah

If you’re comparing companies across Salt Lake and Davis County, most full-service property management fees range from 8% to 12% of your monthly rent.

Here’s what that typically looks like:

Service Type

Typical Utah Cost

What’s Included

ASPM Advantage

Full-Service Management

8–12% of monthly rent

Marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance

Month-to-month contracts, $0 sign-up, in-house team

Tenant Placement Only

50–100% of one month’s rent

Marketing, showings, lease signing

30-day fill guarantee

Lease Renewal

Flat fee or small %

Lease prep, compliance check

Included in service

Maintenance Coordination

10% markup (industry avg.)

Vendor management

Done in-house, no markup

What this really means is that a $2,000 rental might cost about $160–$240 per month in management fees. But the true value is what that payment protects: your time, income, and investment.

For a detailed breakdown of pricing and service options, you can review our transparent cost structure for Utah property owners.

What’s Included in Property Management Fees

Many landlords assume property management fees cover only rent collection, but a strong management company handles far more.

A full-service management plan typically includes:

Property management team coordinating maintenance and tenant services in Utah

  1. Property marketing across major rental sites and local listings

  2. Tenant screening with credit, background, and income verification

  3. Lease management and legal compliance

  4. Rent collection and late fee enforcement

  5. Maintenance coordination and routine inspections

  6. Monthly reporting and year-end financial summaries

At Advanced Solutions Property Management (ASPM), each of these services is handled by specialized in-house teams. Because we manage everything under one roof, we keep costs lower while delivering faster response times and higher tenant satisfaction.

What Affects the Price You Pay

Not every property or landlord has the same needs, and that’s why fees vary. Here’s what impacts what you’ll pay:

Factors that influence property management costs across Salt Lake City neighborhoods

  1. Property Type and Size

    Multi-unit or commercial properties often require more coordination than single-family homes. Learn more about commercial property management services here.

  2. Location

    Areas like Downtown Salt Lake City or Sugar House typically see higher service demand (and rent values) than outlying neighborhoods.

  3. Vacancy Rates

    The longer a unit sits empty, the more cost you absorb. Check our insights on how to reduce vacancy to protect your rental income.

  4. Service Scope

    Some landlords only need leasing, while others prefer full-service management with maintenance and renewals.

  5. Maintenance Model

    Companies that outsource every repair usually charge markups. ASPM’s in-house maintenance team eliminates that extra layer, keeping expenses predictable. You can also read about ways to reduce maintenance costs to increase your ROI.

Here’s the thing: a 1% difference in management fees is meaningless if you’re losing 10% in vacancy. The right manager keeps your property occupied and profitable.

Self-Management vs Professional Management

Let’s compare the two approaches side by side:

Category

Self-Managed

Professional (ASPM)

Tenant Screening

Basic checks

Comprehensive background and income verification

Vacancy Rate

10–15% (avg.)

Under 5%

Eviction Risk

Higher

Less than 1%

Rent Collection

Manual

Automated and enforced

Maintenance

Time-consuming

In-house, cost-controlled

Stress Level

High

Minimal

Most Utah landlords who switch from self-management to professional oversight see measurable gains in ROI within the first year. That’s because the fee often pays for itself in higher retention, fewer issues, and less downtime between tenants.

If you’re unsure whether it’s worth the change, check out Is Hiring a Property Management Company in Salt Lake City Worth the Money?

Why the Right Property Manager Pays for Itself

Think of property management as an investment multiplier rather than an expense.

Utah landlord reviewing ROI growth from professional property management

 

Let’s break it down with a quick example:

  1. Rent: $2,000 per month

  2. Management fee (9%): $180

  3. Vacancy reduced by one week per year: +$240 per month in extra rent

  4. Maintenance cost reduced by 10%: +$100 per month saved

 

Net gain: $160 per month in added value, not loss.

At ASPM, our data shows that owners often earn more after hiring us because we prevent the costly mistakes that eat into profits, such as missed rent, unvetted tenants, or overpriced repairs.

For an in-depth look at your potential returns, use our Free Market Analysis tool to estimate your property’s earning potential.

Building Trust Through Experience

At Advanced Solutions Property Management, we’ve spent more than a decade managing hundreds of Utah rentals across Salt Lake, Davis, and nearby counties. Our leadership team brings over 65 years of combined experience, and we operate with the same mindset as our clients because we’re landlords too.

Our approach is simple: keep properties profitable, tenants happy, and owners informed. That’s why our vacancy rate stays under 5% and our eviction rate under 1%.

Ready to Learn What Property Management Would Cost for You?

Curious what a tailored management plan looks like for your property?

Schedule your Free Expert Rental Strategy Session and find out how much your property could earn under professional management. There’s no sign-up fee, no pressure, just real numbers and honest guidance.

You can also explore our current rental listings to see how we market properties or submit a realtor referral if you’re in the real estate industry.

Frequently Asked Questions About Property Management Costs

Some companies charge setup or onboarding fees, usually between $200 and $500. These are meant to cover account creation, inspections, or initial marketing costs.

At Advanced Solutions Property Management, there are no sign-up or onboarding fees at all. We believe you should only pay once we start delivering value.

For most landlords, yes, especially if you value your time and want consistent, reliable returns.

A good property manager will:

  1. Keep your vacancy rate low by marketing efficiently and pricing correctly
  2. Handle tenant issues quickly before they become costly problems
  3. Ensure rent is collected on time every month
  4. Maintain compliance with Salt Lake City rental laws

    When you factor in the saved time, avoided mistakes, and higher tenant quality, the management fee often pays for itself several times over each year.

Besides the monthly management fee, you may encounter:

  1. Tenant placement fees: typically 50–100% of one month’s rent for finding and screening a new tenant
  2. Renewal fees: a small flat fee or percentage for lease renewals
  3. Maintenance or repair costs: billed as needed. ASPM keeps this in-house to reduce markup costs
  4. Eviction or legal fees: rare, but necessary if a tenant violates their lease

    Every reputable property manager should outline all possible fees clearly in your contract before you sign. Transparency is key to trust.

For more details, you can review our Property Owner FAQ.

Start by looking for three traits:

  1. Local experience – They should understand the Utah rental market and tenant laws.
  2. Transparent pricing – You should know exactly what you’re paying for and when.
  3. Strong communication – Ask how they handle reporting, owner updates, and emergencies.

    Also, read Google reviews, ask for referrals, and review sample reports. Companies like ASPM that provide month-to-month flexibility, detailed owner reports, and low vacancy rates often outperform national franchises.

Explore our Murray Property Management page if you own properties in that area.

Yes, at least with ASPM, you can. Our month-to-month contracts give you total flexibility. Many management companies require six to twelve month commitments or cancellation penalties. We don’t.

If you’re not satisfied, you can cancel anytime without fees. It keeps us accountable and ensures you stay because you’re happy, not because you’re locked in.

Take the Next Step Toward Hassle-Free Property Ownership

If you’ve been weighing the costs of hiring a property manager, remember this: you’re not just paying for convenience. You’re investing in consistent performance, compliance, and peace of mind.

The right management team can turn your property from a source of stress into a reliable income stream.

Ready to see the numbers for yourself? Schedule your Free Expert Rental Strategy Session and discover what professional management can do for your bottom line.

Related Reads:

Advanced Solutions Property Management
Follow Us
Latest posts by Advanced Solutions Property Management (see all)